Fichier PDF

Partagez, hébergez et archivez facilement vos documents au format PDF

Partager un fichier Mes fichiers Boite à outils PDF Recherche Aide Contact



Courriel de Jim Peebles .pdf


Nom original: Courriel de Jim Peebles.pdf
Titre: Courriel de Jim Peebles
Auteur: Jim Peebles

Ce document au format PDF 1.4 a été généré par PDFCreator Version 1.2.0 / GPL Ghostscript 9.0, et a été envoyé sur fichier-pdf.fr le 18/03/2011 à 12:55, depuis l'adresse IP 82.234.x.x. La présente page de téléchargement du fichier a été vue 1038 fois.
Taille du document: 67 Ko (1 page).
Confidentialité: fichier public




Télécharger le fichier (PDF)









Aperçu du document


1 sur 1

about:blank

De : !Jim Peebles <pjep@Princeton.EDU> Objet : ! Rép : Some questions about what you wrote in a French
CMB-related book
Date : ! 6 octobre 2010 19:43:15 HAEC À : !Alain Riazuelo <riazuelo@iap.fr>
Cc : !Igor Bogdanoff <i.bogdanoff@orange.fr>, John C. (GSFC-6600) Mather <john.c.mather@nasa.gov>,
SMOOT@phyweb.lbl.gov
Dear Colleague
I am drawn -- against my wishes -- further into the controversy of the Bogdanovs' book.I feel I must request a clarification in your
notes at http://www2.iap.fr/users/riazuelo/fpc/bog/lvdd/lvdd.php of your quotes from me.
Prior to the quotes in your notes I am identified as la troisième récipiendaire d'un prix prestigieux (Jim Peebles, ...
Among the quotes is the sentence, Le troisième résumera en disant It sounds like I have been duped. Unless my French quite
deceives me the reasonable presumption is that I, as the third person identified, am the one who wrote It sounds like I have
been duped. I cannot believe that; it is not my style at all. I can find only one set of comments I sent to you, as follows :
Dear Colleague Thank you for your comments.
Since my ability to read French has sadly decayed I did not read much of the text written by the Bogdanovs. My recollection
of what I did read includes celebrations of the wonders of the physical universe that perhaps are overly enthusiastic in
parts, but that is their choice. I did not notice
expression of support for intelligent design, but again they surely are free to do so. I do not see any merit in intelligent
design, you will find no support for it in my essay, and I hope that will be recognized by readers of this book.
With best wishes, Jim Peebles
But I on occasion delete email. Maybe you have other comments from me?
In your notes you correctly enter my statement: I do not see any merit in intelligent design, you will find no support for it in my
essay, and I hope that will be recognized by readers of this book.
But it would be fair to enter the context, by including my preceding sentence:
I did not notice expression of support for intelligent design, but again they surely are free to do so.
My urgent requests:
1. please remove the implication that I wrote It sounds like I have been duped.
2. please restore context to my quote.
I do not object to your use of quotations from what I wrote to you, but that is my personal reaction. If Mather and Smoot also
agree to your use of their comments to you, then I suggest that you ought to state which of us said what.
I have no comments on the rest of your notes. As I said, my French has sadly decayed. I hope you understand that I completely
support your right to criticize the book, and to criticize my essay if you so wish. But I am sure you will fully agree that scrupulous
care must be taken in describing the opinions of others!
With all best wishes,
Cheers, Jim

18/03/2011 12:49


Aperçu du document Courriel de Jim Peebles.pdf - page 1/1

Documents similaires


Fichier PDF courriel de jim peebles
Fichier PDF lettre de john mather
Fichier PDF nicolas martigne cv resume 2015
Fichier PDF cv
Fichier PDF cv gabriel dalmasso 2016 en
Fichier PDF arthur fritz cv anglais


Sur le même sujet..