بعض تفاصيل قضية أطروحة الدكتوراه أ.حداد .pdf

‫‪cnesjijel@gmail.com‬‬

‫بعض تفاصٍم قضٍت إبطال أطشٔحت انذكتٕساِ نألستارة طٕيت حذاد‬
‫قسى انشٌاضٍاث‪ -‬جايعت جٍجم‪-‬‬
‫حؼ‪ٛ‬د حفبص‪ ً١‬اٌمض‪١‬ت ئٌ‪ٛٔ ٝ‬فّبش ‪ ،2013‬ز‪١‬ث لبِج اٌّخششست ب‪ٛ‬ضغ ٍِف ِٕبلشت أطش‪ٚ‬زت اٌذوخ‪ٛ‬ساٖ ف‪ٟ‬‬
‫اٌش‪٠‬بض‪١‬بث‪ ،‬ز‪١‬ث ف‪ 11ٟ‬ف‪١‬فش‪ 2014 ٞ‬لبَ اٌّدٍظ اٌؼٍّ‪ ٟ‬ببلخشاذ ٌدٕت إٌّبلشت اٌّخى‪ٔٛ‬ت ِٓ األعبحزة األح‪١‬ت‬
‫أعّبؤُ٘‪:‬‬
‫سئ‪١‬غب‪(.‬أستار سابق بجايعت جٍجم)‬
‫خبِؼت عط‪١‬ف‬
‫أ‪.‬د‪ .‬ػ‪١‬بش ػ‪١‬غ‪ٝ‬‬
‫ػض‪ٛ‬ا‪.‬‬
‫أ‪.‬د‪ .‬بٓ ش‪ٙ‬شة ِ‪ٛ‬فك خبِؼت ع‪١‬ذ‪ ٞ‬بٍؼببط‬
‫ػض‪ٛ‬ا‪.‬‬
‫أ‪.‬د‪ .‬خببٌ‪ ٟ‬ئعّبػ‪ ً١‬اٌّذسعت اٌؼٍ‪١‬ب اٌمبت‬
‫ػض‪ٛ‬ا‪.‬‬
‫خبِؼت خ‪١‬دً‬
‫أ‪.‬د‪٠ .‬بس‪ِ ٚ‬صطف‪ٝ‬‬
‫بؼذ اعخ‪١‬فبء اٌّذة اٌمبٔ‪١ٔٛ‬ت (ش‪ٙ‬ش‪ ،)ٓ٠‬أسعً وً ِٓ األعخبر‪ ٓ٠‬بٓ ش‪ٙ‬شة خببٌ‪ ٟ‬حمش‪٠‬ش‪ ٓ٠‬ئ‪٠‬دبب‪( ٓ١١‬أٔظش اٌّشفمت‬
‫‪ ،)PDF 1،2‬أِب األعخبر‪٠ :‬بس‪ ٚ‬بم‪٠ ٟ‬خّبطً ٌّذة ‪ 8‬أش‪ٙ‬ش(د‪ ْٚ‬الخشاذ حغ‪١‬شٖ ِٓ طشف اٌؼّ‪١‬ذ!)‪ ،‬بؼذ٘ب اسعً‬
‫حمش‪٠‬شا عٍب‪١‬ب غبِضب (أٔظشاٌّشفمت ‪ ، )3‬ز‪١‬ث صشذ أْ ٕ٘بن حشببٗ ب‪ ٓ١‬اٌفصً اٌثبٌث ٌألطش‪ٚ‬زت (اٌّى‪ِٓ ْٛ‬‬
‫ِمبٌ‪ ٓ١‬ف‪ِ ٟ‬دٍخ‪ ٓ١‬د‪١ٌٚ‬خ‪ٚ )ٓ١‬ئزذ‪ِ ٜ‬مبالحٗ إٌّش‪ٛ‬سة‪ .‬بغب ٘زا اٌخمش‪٠‬ش‪ ،‬سئ‪١‬ظ اٌٍدٕت األعخبر ػ‪١‬بش ٌُ ‪٠‬خسًّ‬
‫ِغإ‪١ٌٚ‬ت احخبر لشاس ‪ٚ‬اشخشط خ‪ٛ‬ابب ِٓ اٌّششف ‪ٚ‬الخشذ ػٍ‪ ٝ‬اٌّدٍظ اٌؼٍّ‪ ٟ‬ئِىبٔ‪١‬ت حؼ‪ ٓ١١‬خبشاء ِٓ أخً سفغ‬
‫٘زا االٌخببط (أٔظشاٌّشفمت ‪ ، )6‬د‪ ْٚ‬أْ ‪٠‬دخّغ ِغ أػضبء اٌٍدٕت وّب ‪ٕ٠‬ص ػٍ‪ ٗ١‬اٌمبٔ‪.ْٛ‬‬
‫ف‪٘ ٟ‬زا إٌّؼشج لبَ اٌّدٍظ اٌؼٍّ‪ٌٍ ٟ‬ىٍ‪١‬ت بشئبعت األعخبرة‪ٌ :‬ؼ‪٠ٛ‬شدٌ‪ٍ١‬ت‪ ،‬بّخبٌفت صشٌحت نهًشسٕو انتُفٍذي سقى‬
‫‪ 452-98‬انًؤسخ فً انشبٍع انثاًَ ‪ 4249‬انًٕافق نــ ‪ 47‬أٔث ‪ 4998‬السًٍا انًادة ‪،72 ٔ73‬‬
‫ٔانًُشٕسانٕصاسي انزي ٌسٍش أطشٔحاث انذكتٕساِ‪ٚ ،‬اٌز‪ٕ٠ ٞ‬ص ػٍ‪ ٝ‬أٔٗ ئر ‪ٚ‬خذ حمش‪٠‬شا عٍب‪١‬ب ‪٠‬شعً ٌٍّششف‬
‫‪ٚ‬اٌّخششر ٌٍشد ػٍ‪ ٝ‬االٔخمبداث اٌّ‪ٛ‬خ‪ٛ‬دة ف‪ٚ ،ٗ١‬ف‪ ٟ‬زبٌت سفض االٔخمبداث حؼ‪ٌ ٓ١‬دٕت ِٕبلشت خذ‪٠‬ذة ‪٠‬ى‪ ْٛ‬لشاس٘ب‬
‫ٔ‪ٙ‬بئ‪١‬ب‪.‬‬
‫ٌُ ‪٠‬ؼًّ ػّ‪١‬ذ وٍ‪١‬ت اٌؼٍ‪ َٛ‬اٌذل‪١‬مت ‪ٚ‬اإلػالَ ا‪ ٌٟ٢‬ببٌٕ‪١‬ببت األعخبر ب‪ٔٛ‬بِ‪١‬ظ ػبذ اٌسف‪١‬ظ ب‪ٙ‬زا ئر سفض حغٍ‪ ُ١‬اٌخمش‪٠‬ش‬
‫اٌغٍب‪ٌٍّ ٟ‬ؼٕ‪ ٓ١١‬ببألِش ئال بؼذ ش‪ٙ‬ش‪ ِٓ ٓ٠‬اٌخّبطً ‪ ٚ‬بؼذ حذخً ‪ٚ‬صاسة اٌخؼٍ‪ ُ١‬اٌؼبٌ‪ ٚ ٟ‬اٌبسث اٌؼٍّ‪ ... ٟ‬ف‪ٟ‬‬
‫ز‪ ٓ١‬لشس اٌّدٍظ اٌؼٍّ‪ٌٍ ٟ‬ىٍ‪١‬ت حؼ‪ٌ ٓ١١‬دٕت ِٓ ‪ 3‬أعبحزة ف‪ ٟ‬اٌف‪١‬ض‪٠‬بء ‪ ٚ‬اٌى‪١ّ١‬بء ‪ ٚ‬اإلػالَ ا‪١ٌ ٌٟ٢‬خ‪ٌٛٛ‬ا حؼ‪ٓ١١‬‬
‫خبشاء ف‪ ٟ‬اٌش‪٠‬بض‪١‬بث ٌٍفصً ف‪ ٟ‬اٌمض‪١‬ت ‪ٌّ ٚ‬ب اخخٍف ٘إالء اٌثالثت ‪٠ ٌُ ٚ‬ىٍّ‪ٛ‬ا اٌّ‪ّٙ‬ت اٌّغٕذة ئٌ‪ ُٙ١‬ح‪ ٌٝٛ‬ػّ‪١‬ذ‬
‫اٌىٍ‪١‬ت ببٌٕ‪١‬ببت ( ‪ ِٓ ٛ٘ٚ‬لغُ اٌف‪١‬ض‪٠‬بء) حؼ‪ 3 ٓ١١‬خبشاء ِد‪ ٓ١ٌٛٙ‬ئر ٌُ ‪٠‬ؼشف‪ ُٙ‬ئال ػض‪ ِٓ ٓ٠ٛ‬اٌّدٍظ اٌؼٍّ‪ٟ‬‬
‫ػٕذ دساعت اٌخمبس‪٠‬ش ف‪ ٟ‬اٌّدٍظ اٌؼٍّ‪ٚ(ٟ‬ازذ ِٓ لغُ اٌش‪٠‬بض‪١‬بث أِب ا‪٢‬خش ف‪ ِٓٛٙ‬لغُ اٌف‪١‬ض‪٠‬بء !)‪.‬‬
‫ز‪١‬ث لبَ اٌؼّ‪١‬ذ باسعبي ِمبي ٌألعخبر ‪٠‬بس‪ِٚ ٚ‬مبي ٌألعخبرة زذاد ٔتقشٌش آخش جذٌذ نألستار‪ٌ :‬اسٔ ئٌ‪ ٝ‬انخبشاء‬
‫انًجٕٓنٍٍ‪٘ٚ ،‬زا لبً أْ ‪٠‬خسصً ػٍ‪ ٝ‬انشد انعهًً نألستار انًششف انزي سفض سسًٍا ْزا اإلجشاء انًخانف‬
‫نهقإٌَ (حٍث حٕل يٕضٕع انُضاع يٍ تشابّ بٍٍ انفصم انثانث نألطشٔحت ٔانًقال إنى سشقت عهًٍت يٍ يقال‬
‫إنى آخش ْٕٔ يٍ اختصاص انًجهت انتً َشش فٍٓا ٔانتً أكذث أٌ انًقال ال ٌٕجذ فٍّ اي اشكال)‪.‬‬
‫‪ٚ‬ف‪ِ 05 ٟ‬بسط ‪ ،2015‬خبءث حمبس‪٠‬ش اٌخبشاء اٌّد‪ ٓ١ٌٛٙ‬بٕخبئح غ‪١‬ش فبصٍت‪ ،‬ئر اػخبش ازذُ٘ أْ ال ‪ٚ‬خ‪ٛ‬د‬
‫ٌٍغشلت اٌؼٍّ‪١‬ت ‪ ٚ‬لذَ ا‪٢‬خش حمش‪٠‬شا غبِضب‪ ،‬ف‪ ٟ‬ز‪ ٓ١‬خبء اٌخمش‪٠‬ش األخ‪١‬ش بضػُ أْ ٕ٘بن عشلت ػٍّ‪١‬ت ‪ٛ٘ ٚ‬‬
‫اٌخمش‪٠‬ش اٌّؼخّذ ِٓ لبً اٌّدٍظ اٌؼٍّ‪ٌٍ ٟ‬ىٍ‪١‬ت اٌز‪ ٞ‬أبطً وً ئخشاءاث إٌّبلشت ‪ ٚ‬أٌغ‪ ٝ‬خّ‪١‬غ اٌخغد‪١‬الث‬
‫ِخدب٘ال ٔخبئح حسى‪ ُ١‬اٌّدٍت اٌذ‪١ٌٚ‬ت ‪ِٚ APPLICABLE ANALYSIS‬خدب٘ال أ‪٠‬ضب أْ األطش‪ٚ‬زت حسخ‪ٞٛ‬‬
‫‪1‬‬

‫ػٍ‪ِ ٝ‬مبي د‪ ٌٟٚ‬بؼبًِ اٌخأث‪١‬ش(‪ )I.F‬آخش ٌُ ‪٠‬طشذ ز‪ ٌٗٛ‬أ‪ ٞ‬حسفظ‪ٚ .‬ئٌ‪ِٕٛ٠ ٝ‬ب ٘زا‪ ٌُ ،‬حخر اٌفشصت ٌٍّششف‬
‫ٌ‪١‬طٍغ ػٍ‪٘ ٝ‬زٖ اٌخمبس‪٠‬ش سغُ طٍبٗ ٌ‪ٙ‬ب ِٓ أخً اٌشد ػٍ‪ٙ١‬ب‪.‬‬
‫ز‪١‬ث ‪ٚ‬ببٌّ‪ٛ‬اصاة ِغ ٘زا اإلخشاء اٌز‪ ٞ‬لبَ بٗ ػّ‪١‬ذ اٌىٍ‪١‬ت ببٌٕ‪١‬ببت‪ ،‬لبَ األعخبر ‪٠‬بس‪ ٚ‬صبزب اٌخمش‪٠‬ش اٌغٍب‪ ٟ‬بخبس‪٠‬خ‬
‫‪( 2014/12/06‬أٔظشاٌّشفمبث)‪ ،‬بّشاعٍت اٌّدٍت اٌؼٍّ‪١‬ت اٌّؼش‪ٚ‬فت "‪ " Applicable Analysis‬أ‪٠ ٓ٠‬خ‪ ُٙ‬ف‪ٙ١‬ب‬
‫األعخبر اٌّششف ‪ٚ‬اٌّخششست ببٌغشلت ‪ٚ‬ع‪ٛ‬ء اٌخصشف اٌؼٍّ‪ ٓ١١‬بطش‪٠‬مت بؼ‪١‬ذة خذا ػٓ اٌٍببلت ‪ٚ‬األخالق اٌؼٍّ‪١‬ت‪،‬‬
‫أٔظش اإل‪ :1ً١ّ٠‬اٌّشعً ِٓ طشف األعخبر ‪٠‬بس‪.ٚ‬‬
‫فمبِج ٘‪١‬ئت حسش‪٠‬ش اٌّدٍت بّشاعٍت اٌّششف ٌ‪١‬شد ػٓ ٘زٖ االح‪ٙ‬بِبث اٌخط‪١‬شة ز‪١‬ث لبَ األعخبر زذاد بّشاعٍت‬
‫اٌّدٍت (أٔظش اإل‪ٚ )2ً١ّ٠‬ئسعبي سدٖ اٌؼٍّ‪( ٟ‬أٔظش اٌّشفمت ‪ )4‬خالي اعب‪ٛ‬ع‪.‬‬
‫بؼذ اٌخسى‪ ، ُ١‬لشسث ٘‪١‬ئت حسش‪٠‬ش اٌّدٍت ‪ ،‬بخبس‪٠‬خ ‪ 2015/01/26‬ػذَ ‪ٚ‬خ‪ٛ‬د أ‪ ٞ‬عشلت ػٍّ‪١‬ت (أٔظش اإل‪١ّ٠‬الث‬
‫‪ )5،4،3‬اٌّشعً ِٓ طشف اٌّدٍت‪.‬‬
‫سغُ رٌه لشس ػّ‪١‬ذ اٌىٍ‪١‬ت ببٌٕ‪١‬ببت ‪ٚ‬سئ‪١‬غت اٌّدٍظ اٌؼٍّ‪ ٟ‬اّ٘بي سأ‪ٚ ٞ‬لشاس اٌّدٍت ‪ٚ‬أخظبس حمبس‪٠‬ش اٌخبشاء‬
‫اٌّد‪ ٓ١ٌٛٙ‬اٌّشبس ئٌ‪ ُٙ١‬آٔفب‪.‬‬
‫وّب أوذث اٌّدٍت ‪ Journal of Nonlinear Science and Applications‬اٌخ‪ٔ ٟ‬شش ف‪ٙ١‬ب اٌّمبي اٌثبٔ‪ٟ‬‬
‫(خضء ِٓ اٌفصً اٌثبٌث ‪ٚ‬اٌز‪ ٞ‬وبْ ِسً اٌخسى‪ٌ ُ١‬ذ‪ ٜ‬اٌخبشاء اٌّد‪ )ٓ١ٌٛٙ‬ػذَ ‪ٚ‬خ‪ٛ‬د أ‪ ٞ‬اشىبي ببٌٕغبت ٌ‪ٙ‬زا‬
‫اٌّمبي (أٔظش اإل‪.)6 ً١ّ٠‬‬
‫‪٠‬خب‪ِّ ٓ١‬ب عبك أْ اٌّدٍخ‪ ٓ١‬اٌؼٍّ‪١‬خ‪ ٓ١‬اٌذ‪١ٌٚ‬خ‪ ٓ١‬لبِخب بؼًّ شفبف ‪ ٚ‬ػٍّ‪ ٚ ٟ‬خٍصخب ف‪ٌ ٗ١‬ؼذَ ‪ٚ‬خ‪ٛ‬د أ‪٠‬ت عشلت‬
‫ػٍّ‪١‬ت ‪ ٚ‬أْ إٌخبئح اٌخ‪ ٟ‬ح‪ٛ‬صٍج ئٌ‪ّٙ١‬ب بٍغج ٌدّ‪١‬غ اٌّؼٕ‪ ٓ١١‬ببألِش ( األعخبر ‪٠‬بس‪ ٚ‬ببٌذسخت األ‪ ٌٝٚ‬ثُ ػّ‪١‬ذ اٌىٍ‪١‬ت‬
‫ببٌٕ‪١‬ببت ثُ سئ‪١‬غت اٌّدٍظ اٌؼٍّ‪ٌٍ ٟ‬ىٍ‪١‬ت ثُ ِذ‪٠‬ش اٌدبِؼت فبٌ‪ٛ‬صاسة ) ‪ِ ٚ‬غ ٘زا أصش اٌّدٍظ اٌؼٍّ‪ٌٍ ٟ‬ىٍ‪١‬ت ػٍ‪ٝ‬‬
‫اٌٍد‪ٛ‬ء إلخشاءاث غ‪١‬ش لبٔ‪١ٔٛ‬ت ‪ ٚ‬غ‪١‬ش ػٍّ‪١‬ت ‪.‬‬
‫ئْ ٘زٖ اٌمض‪١‬ت حطشذ خٍّت ِٓ اٌخغبؤالث ‪:‬‬
‫‪ ‬ئْ اٌغشلت اٌؼٍّ‪١‬ت ئْ ‪ٚ‬خذث ‪ ٚ‬بصفت خبصت ف‪ِ ٟ‬بدة ػٍّ‪١‬ت وبٌش‪٠‬بض‪١‬بث ال ‪ّ٠‬ىٓ أْ ‪٠‬خخٍف ف‪ٙ١‬ب‬
‫اثٕبْ ‪ :‬فى‪١‬ف ٌٍدٕت إٌّبلشت أْ حخخٍف ف‪٘ ٟ‬زا ( حمشس‪ ٓ٠‬ا‪٠‬دبب‪ ٚ ٓ١١‬حمش‪٠‬ش عٍب‪ ِٓ ٟ‬األعخبر ‪٠‬بس‪) ٚ‬‬
‫؟ ‪ ٚ‬و‪١‬ف ٌٍخبشاء اٌّد‪ ٓ١ٌٛٙ‬أْ ‪٠‬خخٍف‪ٛ‬ا أ‪٠‬ضب ف‪٘ ٟ‬زا ( حمش‪٠‬ش ‪ٚ‬ازذ ‪٠‬ش‪١‬ش ٌٍغشلت اٌؼٍّ‪١‬ت ) ‪.‬‬
‫‪ ‬لذِج اٌّخششست ‪ ٚ‬اٌّششف ‪ 6‬طؼ‪ٌ ْٛ‬شئبعت اٌدبِؼت ‪ٌٍٛ ٚ‬صاسة اٌ‪ٛ‬ص‪١‬ت د‪ ْٚ‬اٌسص‪ٛ‬ي ػٍ‪ ٝ‬أ‪ ٞ‬سد‬
‫ِٕز أوثش ِٓ عٕت‪.‬‬
‫‪٠ ‬شخشط ٌّٕبلشت أطش‪ٚ‬زت اٌذوخ‪ٛ‬ساٖ ف‪ ٟ‬اٌدبِؼت اٌدضائش‪٠‬ت ٔشش ِمبي ف‪ِ ٟ‬دٍت ػٍّ‪١‬ت د‪١ٌٚ‬ت فٕششث‬
‫اٌّخششست ‪ِ 03‬مبالث ب‪ٙ‬زٖ اٌّدالث ‪٘ ٚ‬زا خذ‪٠‬ش ببالػخببس ‪ ...‬فبح‪ّٙ‬ج ببٌغشلت اٌؼٍّ‪١‬ت ‪ ٚ‬حُ‬
‫االزخىبَ ٌٍّدالث اٌؼٍّ‪١‬ت اٌذ‪١ٌٚ‬ت ِٓ طشف ِٓ ‪ٚ‬خٗ االح‪ٙ‬بَ ‪ ٚ‬فصٍج ٘زٖ اٌّدالث بطش‪٠‬مت شفبفت ‪ٚ‬‬
‫ػٍّ‪١‬ت‪ .‬فخمشس خبِؼت خ‪١‬دً (بً إٌبطم‪ ٓ١‬ببعّ‪ٙ‬ب) ‪ ٚ‬حصش ػٍ‪ٚ ٝ‬خ‪ٛ‬د عشلت ػٍّ‪١‬ت ‪٘ٚ‬زا ‪ّ٠‬ظ‬
‫بغّؼت اٌدبِؼت اٌدضائش‪٠‬ت لبً أْ ‪ّ٠‬ظ بغّؼت األعخبرة زذاد‪.‬ط ‪ٚ‬األعخبر اٌّششف‪.‬‬

‫اإلًٌٍــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــم‪4‬‬
‫________________________‪Accusation de Mr Yarou adressée a la revue‬‬
‫‪Dear Editors,‬‬
‫‪I have a great respect to your journal, and it is with regret that I writes you to‬‬
‫‪denounce a plagiarism in a paper to appear in Applicable Analysis, published‬‬
‫‪2‬‬

online May 19th, 2014 by T. Haddad and T. Haddad entitled "Delay perturbed statedependent sweeping process" .
First, The authors are in breach of the rules of submission for applicable Analysis,
and of the warranty made to Taylor & Francis regarding originality since the authors
failed to cite, reference or acknowledge their previous work published in Journal of
Nonlinear Science and Applications, available online atwww.tjnsa.com, J.
Nonlin.Sci. Appl. 7 (2014), 70-77, ISSN 2008-1901 " Existence of solutions to the
state dependent sweeping process with delay" ( received 2012 -11- 23, I have
attached a copy of the paper).
Only for this reason, the paper must be removed, the two papers deal with the same
problem with the same assumptions, the same method, the same result, the only
difference is the assumption on the set C (t, u (t) ) which is convex in the first and
uniformly r-prox regular in the second, which is a form of local convexity, and all the
experts know that it is enough to choose a finer discretization ie. choose n large
enough to recover the convexity and the proof is exactly the same. (Notice that the
referees of your journal made some important corrections with regard to the first
one).
In fact, there is an obvious likeness between both papers and a result ( theorem 3.5) in
my joint paper with C. Castaing and G. Ibrahim entitled " Some contributions to
nonconvex sweeping process " published in Journal of Nonlinear and Convex
Analysis, Vol. 10, N 1, 2009, 1-20 (see attached file). I leave it to you to check that
there is no scientific contribution and it is the same problem with the same
assumptions, the same method, the same result and the same steps. The only
difference is not fundamental or major and makes no changes to the proof, it concerns
the estimation of the elements of the sequence (equation 4 in the paper), they obtain
our same constant in a classic way while the novelty (and the strength) of our result
lies in the use of the fixed point because our assumptions (C3) depends on t, u and x.
Notice that their algorithm is not new since it was already used by other authors, of
whom Kaadour Chraibi in his Ph D thesis,1987, Montpellier, see the reference :
Kunze M. and Monteiro Marques M.D.P. "On parabolic quasi variational inequalities
and state dependent sweeping process" in Topological Methods in Nonlinear
Analysis, Vol. 12, 1998, 179-191, page 181, line 13.
Notice also that in our paper, we deal with uniformly r-prox regular sets C(t,u(t)); and
as in the case of the second order problem (theorems 3.2 and 3.3), we give the result
with r-prox regularity condition for the problem without perturbation (Theorem 3.4)
and for simplicity we do with convex C for the perturbed problem (theorem 3.5) since
we know how to go to the r-prox regular case.
I understand that the referees cannot know because our paper of JNCA is not
available online, but in my opinion, there is no major scientific contribution in both
papers, I leave you the care of making the necessary decisions.
3

Please let me know your decision.
Best regards.
Mustapha YAROU
Université de Jijel
Département de Mathématiques
Faculté des Sciences
B.P 98, 18000, JIJEL, ALGERIE.

:4 ‫اإلًٌٍــــــــــــــــــــــم‬
================ réponse adressée à la revue=================
From: math haddad <haddadmath1@gmail.com>
Date: 2014-12-15 22:03 GMT+01:00
To: yongzhi.xu@louisville.edu
Cc: gilbert@math.udel.edu

Dear editor
Although the author of the comments has used a heavy vocabulary (plagiarism,
stupidity, violated,…) we prove scientifically that all points of comments are false
and unfounded with several arguments. See our responses in the attached file.Please
let us know your decision. Please send us a reply to acknowledge your receiving this
email.
Sincerly yours
Touma HADDAD and Tahar HADDAD
Département de Mathématiques
Université de Jijel
ALGERIE

:3 ‫اإلًٌٍـــــــــــــــــــــــــــــم‬
Forwarded message ---------From: Gray, Helen <Helen.Gray@tandf.co.uk>
Date: 2015-01-26 13:16 GMT+01:00
Subject: Confidential: Applicable Analyis
To: "haddadmath1@gmail.com" <haddadmath1@gmail.com>

Dear Mustapha Yarou
Thank you for this e-mail. This has been investigated in depth by the Editors of the
Journal and the Publisher, Taylor & Francis. We are satisfied that no misconduct has
occurred and this matter will now be considered closed.
Yours Sincerely
Helen
Helen Gray – Publishing Editor
4

Taylor & Francis/Routledge Journals
Taylor & Francis Group.
4 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon, OX14 4RN, UK.
Tel:
+44 (20) 755 19435
Web: www.tandfonline.com
e-mail: helen.gray@tandf.co.uk
Taylor & Francis is a trading name of Informa UK Limited,
registered in England under no. 1072954

:2‫اإلًٌٍـــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــم‬
--------- Forwarded message ---------From: Gray, Helen <Helen.Gray@tandf.co.uk>
Date: 2015-01-26 13:20 GMT+01:00
Subject: RE: Applicable Analysis Paper
To: "haddadmath1@gmail.com" <haddadmath1@gmail.com>
Dear Touma and Tahar Haddad,
Many thanks for your response to the Editors regarding your paper published in
Applicable Analysis. I am the Publishing Editor for the Journal at Taylor & Francis.
This case has been investigated in depth by us and the Editors, and we are satisfied
with the response provided.
Best
Helen

wishes,

Helen Gray – Publishing Editor
Taylor & Francis/Routledge Journals
Taylor & Francis Group.
4 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon, OX14 4RN, UK.
Tel:
+44 (20) 755 19435
Web: www.tandfonline.com
e-mail: helen.gray@tandf.co.uk
Taylor & Francis is a trading name of Informa UK Limited,
registered in England under no. 1072954

:5‫اإلًٌٍــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــم‬
---------- Forwarded message ---------From: <yongzhi.xu@louisville.edu>
Date: 2015-03-06 16:43 GMT+01:00
Subject: The paper Delay perturbed state-dependent sweeping process
To: "haddadmath1@gmail.com" <haddadmath1@gmail.com>, "mfyarou@yahoo.fr"
<mfyarou@yahoo.fr>, "a.bounames@gmail.com" <a.bounames@gmail.com>,
"secret_doy_fsei@univ-jijel.dz " <secret_doy_fsei@univ-jijel.dz >
5

Cc: "'Robert Gilbert' (gilbert@udel.edu)" <gilbert@udel.edu>, "Gray, Helen
(Helen.Gray@tandf.co.uk)" <Helen.Gray@tandf.co.uk>
To whom it may concern:
The paper "Delay perturbed state-dependent sweeping process" by Tahar
Haddad and Touma Haddad is published in Applicable Analysis, Taylor and
Francis, Online May (2014). We have investigate the plagiarism complain and
concluded that this is not a plagiarism problem.
Sincerely,
Professor Yongzhi Steve Xu
Co-Editor in Chief of Applicable Analysis

:6‫اإلًٌٍـــــــــــــــــــم‬
Le Mardi 17 mars 2015 20h40, Journal of Nonlinear Science and Applications
"editorial-office@tjnsa.com" <editorial-office@tjnsa.com> a écrit :
Dear Haddad,
Your paper has not any problem.
Best wishes
Editorial office JNSA (In Chief)

6